The Question is from neet-botany biodiversity what-is-living, and it was created by the author K SURESH KUMAR

Question

A researcher observes an isolated system containing complex organic molecules undergoing spontaneous self-assembly into membrane-bound structures. These structures exhibit rudimentary metabolism but no reproduction or heritability.  Which characteristic of life is the MOST significant barrier preventing these structures from being classified as living organisms?

K SURESH KUMAR · Accepted Answer

## CORE INFORMATION
✓ **Answer**: C
## CONCEPT FRAMEWORK
 **Primary Concept**: Characteristics of Life
 **Related Topics**:  Abiogenesis, Self-Assembly, Biological Organization
 **Prerequisites**: Understanding the key characteristics typically used to define life (metabolism, reproduction, adaptation, growth, response to stimuli, homeostasis, organization).
## SOLUTION PATHWAY
**Given Information**:
  - Complex organic molecules self-assemble into membrane-bound structures.
  - Structures exhibit rudimentary metabolism.
  - No reproduction or heritability.
**Method & Steps**:
 1. Analyze the characteristics of life presented in the options and compare them to the observed structures.
  Reasoning:  All the options (metabolism, cellular organization, reproduction and growth, adaptation) are characteristics associated with life.  However,  the question asks for the *most significant* barrier.
 2. Evaluate the significance of each characteristic in the context of the observed structures.
  Working: 
            * **Metabolism:** The structures show rudimentary metabolism, so this isn't the primary barrier.
            * **Cellular organization:** The structures are membrane-bound, fulfilling this criterion.
            * **Reproduction and growth:** The structures lack both reproduction and heritability. This is crucial for the continuation of a lineage and evolution. Without it, the structures are essentially ephemeral.
            * **Adaptation:** Adaptation is a consequence of reproduction and selection.  Without reproduction, adaptation cannot occur.
 3. Determine the most significant barrier.
  Result: The absence of reproduction and heritability is the most significant barrier preventing classification as a living organism.  Without these, the structures cannot evolve or persist beyond their immediate existence.  Metabolism, while important for life, is not sufficient for defining life on its own.
  Verification:  The definition of life emphasizes the ability to replicate and pass on genetic information. The lack of this ability is a fundamental difference between living and non-living systems.
 ## OPTION ANALYSIS
A :x: Metabolism is present, so it's not the primary barrier.
B :x: Cellular organization is present.
C ✓: Reproduction and growth (specifically, the lack thereof) is the most significant barrier.  Without reproduction, the structures cannot perpetuate themselves and are effectively a temporary phenomenon.
D :x: Adaptation is dependent on reproduction and selection; the lack of reproduction prevents adaptation.
 ## LEARNING AIDS
 **Common Mistakes**:
  1. Focusing solely on metabolism:  Metabolism is important, but reproduction and heritability are fundamental to the definition of life.
  2. Overlooking the significance of heritability:  Heritability ensures that advantageous traits are passed on, allowing for evolution and adaptation.
 **Quick Tips**:
  1. Remember the central dogma of molecular biology: DNA → RNA → Protein.  Reproduction requires the transfer of genetic information.
  2. Consider the long-term persistence of a system.  Without reproduction, a system cannot survive beyond its immediate existence.

K SURESH KUMAR · Answer

Metabolism

K SURESH KUMAR · Answer

Cellular organization

K SURESH KUMAR · Answer

The correct Option is "Reproduction and growth"

K SURESH KUMAR · Answer

Adaptation

NEET Botany Diversity in Living World What Is Living MCQs

Select Topic

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

NEET Subjects

Our Bots

Company