The Question is from neet-botany biodiversity what-is-living, and it was created by the author NISHANTH

Question

Viruses exhibit characteristics of both living and non-living entities. Which of the following properties of viruses MOST strongly supports the argument AGAINST their classification as living organisms?

NISHANTH · Accepted Answer

## CORE INFORMATION
✓ **Answer**: C
## CONCEPT FRAMEWORK
 **Primary Concept**: Characteristics of living organisms
 **Related Topics**: Virology, Cell biology
 **Prerequisites**: Understanding of the characteristics of life (e.g., reproduction, metabolism, growth)
## SOLUTION PATHWAY
**Given Information**:
  Viruses possess some characteristics of living organisms and some of non-living entities.
  We need to identify the property that strongly argues against classifying them as living.
**Method & Steps**:
 1. Analyze each option to determine its relevance to the definition of life.
  Reasoning: Living organisms typically exhibit the ability to reproduce independently, metabolize, grow, respond to stimuli, and maintain homeostasis.
 2. Evaluate which option most strongly contradicts these characteristics of life.
  Working: 
        * Option A (Presence of genetic material):  Viruses do have genetic material, which is a characteristic sometimes associated with life, but not sufficient on its own.
        * Option B (Ability to evolve and adapt):  Evolution and adaptation are observed in viruses, indicating a capacity for change over time, a characteristic of life, but not sufficient on its own.
        * Option C (Inability to reproduce independently outside a host cell): This is a crucial characteristic. Viruses require a host cell's machinery to replicate; they cannot reproduce independently.  This strongly argues against classifying them as living organisms.
        * Option D (Specific interaction with host cells):  While viruses interact specifically with host cells, this does not directly address the fundamental definition of life.
 3. Identify the option that most decisively indicates a non-living nature.
  Result: Option C
  Verification: The inability to reproduce independently is a fundamental difference between viruses and living organisms.  All other options present characteristics that could be argued for or against classifying viruses as living, but option C provides the strongest argument against.
 ## OPTION ANALYSIS
A :x: Presence of genetic material is a characteristic found in living organisms, but not sufficient to define life on its own. Viruses possess genetic material.
B :x: The ability to evolve and adapt is a characteristic of living organisms, suggesting a capacity for change over time. Viruses exhibit this.
C ✓: The inability to reproduce independently is a key characteristic that distinguishes viruses from living organisms. Viruses require a host cell to replicate.
D :x: Specific interaction with host cells is a property of viruses, but doesn't directly address whether they are living or non-living.
 ## LEARNING AIDS
 **Common Mistakes**:
  1.Confusing the presence of genetic material with the ability to independently reproduce:  Genetic material is present in both living and non-living entities; independent reproduction is a key defining feature of life.
  2.Overemphasizing the ability to evolve and adapt: While evolution is a hallmark of life, it is not sufficient to define life, as viruses also evolve.
 **Quick Tips**:
  1.Focus on the core characteristics of life (reproduction, metabolism, growth, response to stimuli, homeostasis).
  2.Consider what makes viruses fundamentally different from other living entities.

NISHANTH · Answer

Presence of genetic material (DNA or RNA)

NISHANTH · Answer

Ability to evolve and adapt to their environment

NISHANTH · Answer

The correct Option is "Inability to reproduce independently outside a host cell"

NISHANTH · Answer

Specific interaction with host cells

NEET Botany Diversity in Living World What Is Living MCQs

Select Topic

Question Tags

NEET Subjects

Our Bots

Company