The Question is from neet-botany biodiversity , and it was created by the author B VENKAT

Question

While classifying organisms, which of the following presents the biggest challenge to a strictly phylogenetic system of classification?

B VENKAT · Accepted Answer

## CORE INFORMATION
✓ **Answer**: B
## CONCEPT FRAMEWORK
 **Primary Concept**: Phylogenetic classification and its challenges
 **Related Topics**: Convergent evolution, horizontal gene transfer, fossil record, homology, analogy
 **Prerequisites**: Understanding of phylogenetic trees, evolutionary processes, and classification systems.
## SOLUTION PATHWAY
**Given Information**:
The question asks about the biggest challenge to a strictly phylogenetic system of classification.
**Method & Steps**:
1. Analyze each option's impact on phylogenetic classification.
  Reasoning: A strictly phylogenetic system aims to group organisms based solely on their evolutionary relationships, reflecting their shared ancestry.
2. Evaluate the disruptive potential of each option.
  Working:
  * **Convergent evolution:**  Organisms from different lineages may independently evolve similar traits due to similar environmental pressures. This creates analogous structures that can mislead phylogenetic analysis if only morphology is considered. However, molecular data can often reveal the true evolutionary relationships.
  * **Horizontal gene transfer:** This is the movement of genetic material between organisms other than by the transmission of DNA from parent to offspring (vertical transmission). It can significantly alter an organism's genome, obscuring its true phylogenetic position. This is particularly problematic for prokaryotes.
  * **Fossil record incompleteness:** While a challenge, the incompleteness of the fossil record doesn't fundamentally undermine the concept of phylogeny.  Phylogenetic analyses often rely on extant (living) species and can incorporate fossil data when available.
  * **Morphological similarities in unrelated species:**  This is essentially convergent evolution, already discussed above.
 3. Identify the most significant challenge.
  Result: Horizontal gene transfer presents the biggest challenge because it can directly alter the genetic makeup of an organism, making it difficult to accurately reconstruct its evolutionary history based solely on its genetic information.
  Verification: Consider that convergent evolution can be mitigated by using multiple data sources (morphology, genetics).  Incomplete fossil records leave gaps but don't invalidate the fundamental principles of phylogeny.  However, horizontal gene transfer is a powerful force that directly affects the genetic basis of phylogeny.
 ## OPTION ANALYSIS
A :x: Convergent evolution can lead to misleading morphological similarities, but these can be overcome by using molecular data.
B ✓: Horizontal gene transfer directly alters the genetic makeup, making it difficult to construct accurate phylogenetic trees.
C :x: Incomplete fossil records are a limitation but don't invalidate the phylogenetic approach.
D :x: Morphological similarities in unrelated species are a consequence of convergent evolution, already addressed.
 ## LEARNING AIDS
 **Common Mistakes**:
  1.Confusing homology (shared ancestry) with analogy (convergent evolution): Remember that phylogenetic classification relies on homology.
  2.Overlooking the impact of horizontal gene transfer:  Recognize that it directly affects the genetic basis of phylogeny.
 **Quick Tips**:
  1.When analyzing phylogenetic challenges, consider the direct impact on genetic information.
  2.Remember that phylogenetic classification seeks to reflect evolutionary relationships based on shared ancestry.

B VENKAT · Answer

Convergent evolution

B VENKAT · Answer

The correct Option is "Horizontal gene transfer"

B VENKAT · Answer

Fossil record incompleteness

B VENKAT · Answer

Morphological similarities in unrelated species

NEET Botany Diversity in Living World MCQs

Select Topic

Question Tags

NEET Subjects

Our Bots

Company