The Question is from neet-botany , and it was created by the author B VENKAT

Question

Consider a theoretical organism that utilizes silicon as its primary structural element instead of carbon.  Assuming all other characteristics of life are present, which fundamental biological process would be MOST significantly challenged by this substitution?

B VENKAT · Accepted Answer

## CORE INFORMATION
✓ **Answer**: B
## CONCEPT FRAMEWORK
 **Primary Concept**: Comparative biochemistry and the unique properties of carbon.
 **Related Topics**:  Organic chemistry, biomolecule formation, silicon chemistry.
 **Prerequisites**: Understanding of covalent bonding, the importance of carbon's tetravalency and ability to form long chains and rings in organic molecules.
## SOLUTION PATHWAY
**Given Information**:
  A theoretical organism uses silicon instead of carbon.
  All other characteristics of life are assumed to be present.
**Method & Steps**:
 1. Compare the chemical properties of carbon and silicon.
  Reasoning: Carbon's ability to form stable, diverse, and complex molecules is crucial for life.  We need to examine how silicon differs.
  Formula/Rule: None directly applicable, but understanding of covalent bonding is key.
 2. Analyze how silicon's properties affect biomolecule formation.
  Working: Silicon, while also tetravalent, forms weaker Si-Si and Si-O bonds compared to C-C and C-O bonds.  Silicon also has a greater tendency to form strong bonds with oxygen, leading to the formation of stable silicates (sand, quartz) rather than long, flexible chains like carbon.
  Key Point: The relative instability and lower diversity of silicon-based molecules make forming complex, stable biomolecules significantly more difficult.
 3. Evaluate the impact on other biological processes.
  Result: While silicon substitution might affect other processes, the formation of complex, stable biomolecules (proteins, carbohydrates, lipids, nucleic acids) would be the most severely hampered.
  Verification: Carbon's unique properties are central to the structural diversity and stability of biological molecules. Silicon lacks these properties to the same extent.
 ## OPTION ANALYSIS
[A] :x: Cellular respiration: While silicon might affect the structure of enzymes involved in respiration, it's not as fundamentally challenged as biomolecule formation.
[B] ✓: Formation of complex, stable biomolecules: Silicon's weaker bonds and tendency towards silicate formation severely limits its ability to create the diverse and complex molecules essential for life.
[C] :x: Active transport across membranes:  Membrane structure might be altered, but this is a secondary effect compared to the inability to form the basic building blocks of life.
[D] :x: Photosynthesis: Photosynthesis relies on specific molecules, but the fundamental challenge is in building those molecules in the first place.
 ## LEARNING AIDS
 **Common Mistakes**:
  1.Focusing on a single property of silicon (e.g., tetravalency) without considering its limitations compared to carbon:  Tetravalency is necessary but not sufficient for building the complexity of life's molecules.
  2.Overlooking the importance of bond strength and stability: The weaker Si-Si bonds are crucial for understanding why silicon is less suitable for complex biomolecules.
 **Quick Tips**:
  1.Compare the bond energies and stabilities of C-C, C-O, Si-Si, and Si-O bonds. This highlights the key differences.
  2.Remember the diversity and stability of carbon-based organic molecules are unparalleled in silicon chemistry.

B VENKAT · Answer

Cellular respiration

B VENKAT · Answer

The correct Option is "Formation of complex, stable biomolecules"

B VENKAT · Answer

Active transport across membranes

B VENKAT · Answer

Photosynthesis

NEET Botany MCQs

Select Chapter

Question Tags

NEET Subjects

Our Bots

Company