The Question is from neet-physics units-and-measurement limitations-of-dimensional-analysis, and it was created by the author SUBHANI

Question

A student attempts to derive the formula for the period of a simple pendulum using dimensional analysis.  They correctly identify the relevant variables as length (L), mass (m), and gravitational acceleration (g).  Which of the following represents a fundamental limitation they will encounter?

SUBHANI · Accepted Answer

## CORE INFORMATION
✓ **Answer**: Option A
## CONCEPT FRAMEWORK
	**Primary Concept**: Dimensional Analysis
	**Related Topics**: Simple Pendulum, Period, Physical Dimensions
	**Prerequisites**: Understanding of dimensional analysis and the variables influencing a simple pendulum.
## SOLUTION PATHWAY
**Given Information**:
	* Variables: Length (L), mass (m), gravitational acceleration (g)
	* Goal: Derive the formula for the period of a simple pendulum using dimensional analysis.
**Method & Steps**:
	1.  **Understanding Dimensional Analysis Limitation:** Dimensional analysis can only determine the relationships between physical quantities based on their fundamental dimensions (like length, mass, and time). It cannot determine dimensionless numerical constants.
		Reasoning: Dimensional analysis is a tool that ensures equations are consistent in terms of units but does not provide numerical factors.
		Formula/Rule:  If $T = k L^a m^b g^c$ where $T$ is period, $k$ is a dimensionless constant, the exponents $a, b, c$ can be determined by equating dimensions on both sides.
	2. **Applying Dimensional Analysis to the Simple Pendulum:**
		Working:  The dimensions of period T is [T], Length L is [L], mass m is [M], gravitational acceleration g is [L][T]^-2. In the equation $T = k L^a m^b g^c$, equating dimensions we get $[T] = [L]^a [M]^b [L]^c [T]^{-2c}$. This implies $a+c = 0$, $b = 0$, and $-2c = 1$. Hence $c = -1/2$, and $a = 1/2$. So, $T = k \sqrt{L/g}$.
		Key Point: Dimensional analysis will give the form of the equation but not the value of k.
	3. **Identifying the Limitation:**
		Result: The dimensional analysis will correctly determine that the period is proportional to $\sqrt{L/g}$, but it will not reveal that the numerical constant is $2\pi$.
		Verification: The actual formula for the period of a simple pendulum is $T = 2\pi \sqrt{L/g}$.
 ## OPTION ANALYSIS
[A] ✓: This is correct. Dimensional analysis cannot determine the numerical constant in the formula, like the $2\pi$ in the pendulum formula.
[B] :x: Dimensional analysis doesn't directly handle trigonometric functions. However, the simple pendulum formula doesn't directly involve trigonometric functions in the final form for small angle approximations. The approximation makes the motion simple harmonic, and this analysis would still be valid and the limitation remains the constant.
[C] :x: Mass is not a relevant variable for the period of a simple pendulum in the small angle approximation, and dimensional analysis would show that the exponent for mass is zero. However, the question is about the limitations of dimensional analysis itself, not about whether the student included a wrong variable. 
[D] :x: Dimensional analysis can handle non-linear relations as we saw that period is proportional to square root of L/g, it is not limited to linear relationships. The key limitation is the constant.
 ## LEARNING AIDS
	**Common Mistakes**:
		1. **Confusing Dimensional Analysis with Full Derivation:** Students often think dimensional analysis can derive the complete formula.  It can only give the relationships between quantities and not the numerical constants.
		2. **Misunderstanding the Scope:** Students often incorrectly think that dimensional analysis is the only way to analyze physical relationships. It's a tool, not the only method.
	**Quick Tips**:
		1. **Remember the Constant:** When using dimensional analysis, always be mindful that it cannot determine dimensionless constants.
		2. **Dimension Check:** Always verify the dimensions of your results to ensure consistency.

SUBHANI · Answer

The correct Option is "Inability to determine the numerical constant in the formula."

SUBHANI · Answer

Dimensional analysis cannot handle the trigonometric functions involved in the derivation.

SUBHANI · Answer

Mass (m) is not a relevant variable for the period of a simple pendulum, making the analysis invalid.

SUBHANI · Answer

Dimensional analysis can only be used for linear relationships between variables.

NEET Physics Units And Measurement Limitations Of Dimensional Analysis MCQs

Select Topic

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

NEET Subjects

Our Bots

Company