The Question is from neet-botany , and it was created by the author B VENKAT

Question

While creating a phylogenetic tree for a genus of insects, a taxonomist finds conflicting information between a recently published monograph and a classical museum catalogue. Which resource should be prioritized and why?

B VENKAT · Accepted Answer

## CORE INFORMATION
✓ **Answer**: B
## CONCEPT FRAMEWORK
 **Primary Concept**: Phylogenetic analysis and taxonomic prioritization
 **Related Topics**:  Taxonomic nomenclature, molecular phylogenetics, museum collections, scientific literature
 **Prerequisites**: Understanding of phylogenetic tree construction, the importance of updated taxonomic classifications, and the limitations of historical data.
## SOLUTION PATHWAY
**Given Information**:
  Conflicting information between a recently published monograph and a classical museum catalogue.
  The goal is to create a phylogenetic tree for a genus of insects.
**Method & Steps**:
 1. Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each resource.
  Reasoning: Museum catalogues represent historical data, which may be outdated or based on limited information. Monographs often integrate newer molecular data and phylogenetic analyses, leading to more accurate and updated classifications.
  Formula/Rule: None directly applicable.
 2. Consider the reliability and recency of information.
  Working:  Molecular data and comprehensive phylogenetic analyses provide a more robust foundation for building phylogenetic trees than older, potentially less precise methods.
  Key Point: Scientific knowledge evolves. Newer research often supersedes older findings.
 3. Prioritize the resource that provides the most reliable and up-to-date information.
  Result: The monograph should be prioritized.
  Verification: The choice aligns with current best practices in taxonomic and phylogenetic research, emphasizing the importance of incorporating the latest scientific findings.
 ## OPTION ANALYSIS
A :x:  While museum catalogues are valuable historical records, they may not reflect current understanding of phylogenetic relationships due to advancements in molecular techniques and analyses.
B ✓: Monographs often represent the culmination of extensive research, incorporating the latest molecular data and phylogenetic analyses, making them a more reliable source for constructing current phylogenetic trees.
C :x:  Giving equal weight might lead to inaccuracies if the monograph contains more up-to-date information which supersedes the older data in the catalogue.
D :x: Field guides are primarily for species identification and do not provide the comprehensive phylogenetic data needed for constructing a phylogenetic tree.
 ## LEARNING AIDS
 **Common Mistakes**:
  1.Overemphasizing historical precedence over current scientific evidence:  Older resources are not automatically more accurate.
  How to avoid: Consider the methods and data used in each resource, prioritizing those using the most current and reliable techniques.
  2.Failing to consider the limitations of different data types:  Morphological data alone may be insufficient for resolving phylogenetic relationships.
  How to avoid: Understand the strengths and weaknesses of different data types (morphological, molecular, etc.) and use the most appropriate data for the research question.
 **Quick Tips**:
  1.Prioritize peer-reviewed publications, especially recent monographs, for phylogenetic analysis.
  2.Always critically evaluate the sources you use, considering the methodology, data used, and publication date.

B VENKAT · Answer

The museum catalogue, due to its historical precedence and established nomenclature.

B VENKAT · Answer

The correct Option is "The monograph, as it likely incorporates newer molecular data and revised classifications."

B VENKAT · Answer

Equal weight to both, synthesizing the information.

B VENKAT · Answer

Neither, consult a field guide for practical identification.

NEET Botany MCQs

Select Chapter

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

Question Tags

NEET Subjects

Our Bots

Company